I’m sure there are a lot of answers to this. Good prep, a badass boss fight, some serious backstory roleplay, amazing treasures—and these are all good elements. But the most important thing has absolutely nothing to do with the encounters or the adventure itself.

It is the willingness to be there and be involved.

GMs know this, and do everything they can to encourage engagement. They plan hooks, create unique magical items, and provide encounters that allow characters to use their skills. Besides being the storyteller and referee, the GM is the agent provocateur, constantly encouraging players to interact with the world around them.

I’ve run a lot of different tables, from new players to seasoned veterans and everything in between. And from experience, the GM’s biggest nemesis is the disengaged player.The one who has no backstory and barely reacts when his character nearly dies.

The one who, when faced with an open pit and an NPC dangling over the edge, looks at the GM and asks, “What do you want me to do now?”A lot of GMs would jump in at this point and say, quite pointedly, that if they’ve provided an entire world, it’s the player’s responsibility to interact with that world. And they’re not entirely wrong.

Engagement is a shared responsibility, for certain.

As a GM, there are a number of reasons why your players might seem disengaged. Before deciding the player is the problem, it’s worth considering a few possibilities.

1. Some Players Are Just Quieter

This doesn’t mean they aren’t enjoying the game.

Do a quick check-in and ask your players if they are happy with how the sessions have been going. Ask what else they would like to see, whether they want a more prominent role in the next couple of sessions, or if they would enjoy a personal storyline.

Just know that if they are content to be a party member and not in the spotlight, that’s completely fine.

TTRPGs tend to attract some big personalities, too, but that doesn’t mean the quiet player needs to become one.

2. Big Personalities

Every GM knows these players at their table. The ones who “accidentally” turn a whole village against the party by acting before thinking.

They’re fun players, to be sure, but they can hog the spotlight.As a GM, you’ll want to balance encounters to offer a main role to other characters sometimes. Have an NPC speak only a language the quieter player’s character understands, or have that character discover an important clue.

Carefully planted opportunities can draw quieter players into the adventure without forcing them into the spotlight.

3. GM Information

Do the players actually have enough information to act upon your hook, story, or encounter?

We are all guilty of this.

You, the GM, create a big encounter. Every detail is inside your head, but you forget to include something important in the read-aloud text or GM information.

Or, more commonly, new players simply don’t know what they can and cannot do.

Clarity here is the cure.

Before running the game, have a neutral third party read your scene and confirm that the information is clear enough for even the thickest character to come up with some type of response.You don’t need to tell the players what to do.

You need to give them enough information to decide what they want to do.

4. Monotony

This is where players become disengaged because everything is the same. No new challenges, no surprises, no meaningful decisions.

I’m sure we’ve all heard something like this:

“Oh, it’s a random encounter.”

“Is it goblins or trolls this time?”“I’m rolling initiative.”

“If we kill six more of these, maybe something different will come out of the hole in the ground.”

This isn’t actually an issue with repetition.

Killing another goblin when the outcome has meaning is not the same as killing another goblin for no reason.

What if this goblin is the nephew of the goblin king? And now the party is being hunted not just by goblins, but by mercenaries of all types?

Now the encounter matters.

When players believe their actions matter, for better or worse, they become much more engaged.

Player Responsibilities

Let’s say you’ve done all of this, and the player still isn’t engaged.Players have responsibilities, too. At a minimum, they should:

– Pay attention. Follow what’s happening during the game, even when their character isn’t the focus.

– Learn what their characters can do. Players don’t need to memorize every rule, but they should understand their character’s basic abilities.

– Show interest in the adventure. The GM can provide an entire world, but the players need to be willing to interact with it.

– Allow other players to participate. Everyone deserves the opportunity to contribute to the story.

A GM can create interesting NPCs, meaningful encounters, difficult decisions, and a world that responds to the characters’ actions. But they cannot make those decisions for the players.

A great D&D session doesn’t happen because the GM has prepared the perfect adventure.

It happens when everyone at the table is willing to participate in creating the story.

Leave a Reply